Why Are Top Manufacturers Ditching 4 Cylinders for 3?
3-cylinder powerhouse is omnipresent in almost every vehicle in India, be it hatchbacks, sedans, SUVs, buses, trucks, motorcycles, or even generators. It’s fascinating to note that, despite their prevalence, all these machines share a common trait—a four-cylinder engine.
It’s no exaggeration to claim that the 4-cylinder engine is the most versatile globally, finding its application in various vehicles and machinery. Renowned for their smooth operation, 4-cylinder engines offer enhanced mileage with substantial power, making them a favorite among auto manufacturers. However, a noticeable shift has occurred in recent times.
If we rewind 5-6 years, almost every car in India boasted a 4-cylinder engine, from the Hyundai i10 to the Toyota Fortuner with its robust 3000 CC engine. The 4-cylinder engines were celebrated for their smoothness and efficiency. Yet, a change is underway.
Presently, models like the Skoda Kushaq, Volkswagen Taigun, and even larger vehicles like the Mahindra Bolero have adopted the 3-cylinder engine trend. Even Ford Figo and Volkswagen Polo transitioned to 3-cylinder engines before exiting the Indian market. This shift is noteworthy as these cars were once acclaimed for their performance.
Today, Tata Motors heavily relies on 3-cylinder engines, with exceptions like the Safari and Harrier. This shift is not confined to India alone; 3-cylinder engines have rapidly spread to European and various Asian countries. Even in the United States, known for its preference for overpowered vehicles, certain Ford Bronco variants have embraced 3-cylinder engines.
Now, the question arises: why the transition from well-performing 4-cylinder engines to 3-cylinder engines? In this article, we’ll delve into the evolution of engine sizes, exploring the global shift towards 3-cylinder engines and understanding their emergence as a significant player in the automotive industry.
The History of Engine Evolution
The reputation of 3-cylinder engines was not always stellar. Initially notorious for their unrefined characteristics, these engines were sidelined for a long time. The world’s first 4-cylinder engine debuted in 1862, with the Daimler Phoenix being the first car to utilize it. However, until the 1930s, cars, limited to the extremely affluent, predominantly featured 6-8 cylinder engines. The size of engines gradually decreased, making 4-cylinder engines popular.
The first instance of a 3-cylinder engine appeared in 1955, courtesy of German carmaker DKW. While 3-cylinder engines gained traction in Japan, they remained largely unused elsewhere due to poor refinement and being underpowered.
Understanding the Drawbacks
To comprehend why 3-cylinder engines had drawbacks, let’s delve into the basic mechanism of a four-stroke engine. A 4-stroke engine consists of four strokes: intake, compression, power, and exhaust. In a 4-cylinder engine, the firing order has a 180-degree difference between strokes, ensuring continuous power. However, 3-cylinder engines have a 240-degree difference, leading to intermittent power, reduced performance, and increased vibrations.
Another factor contributing to the vibration issue is the imbalanced nature of 3-cylinder engines. As the number of cylinders decreases, refinement diminishes. While some companies add extra counterweights to address this, the result is still a far cry from the smooth operation of a 4-cylinder engine.
The Rise of 3-Cylinder Engines: The Compulsion
Despite their drawbacks, 3-cylinder engines have gained prominence due to compelling reasons. One major driver is the push for fuel efficiency, particularly as petrol and diesel prices surge globally. However, this is not the sole factor; taxes play a pivotal role in shaping the automotive landscape.
In December 2022, the Indian government announced a 22% cases on vehicles meeting specific conditions. SUVs with engine capacities exceeding 1500 CC, an overall length beyond 4000 mm, and a ground clearance above 170 mm fell under this taxation umbrella. Similar tax structures exist in China, Hong Kong, France, and various European Union countries, all influencing manufacturers to produce fuel-efficient, low-emission vehicles.
The Advantages of 3-Cylinder Engines
Despite their unrefined image, 3-cylinder engines offer distinct advantages. Their lightweight and compact size reduce raw material usage, resulting in more affordable vehicles. Additionally, their efficiency shines through, with less fuel consumption and heat loss due to fewer moving parts.
To counter the power issue, manufacturers are now incorporating turbochargers into 3-cylinder engines. Brands like BMW, Mini Cooper, Volvo, and Mazda have successfully implemented these engines in performance-oriented vehicles. Turbochargers enhance power but come with their own set of challenges, particularly in terms of acceleration.
The Future of IC Engines
It’s evident that 3-cylinder engines are not universally loved by driving enthusiasts and auto manufacturers. Tata Motors, once known for its 4-cylinder engines, has shifted to 3-cylinder engines to address fuel efficiency and emission concerns. However, this move has impacted the overall perception of their engines.
As we delve into the era of 3-cylinder engines, it’s crucial to view them as potentially the last stage of internal combustion engines. Car manufacturers are reaching the limits of technological advancements, and further improvements necessitate either reducing the number of cylinders or significantly reducing vehicle weight. Suzuki exemplifies this approach, achieving high efficiency in its cars with 4-cylinder engines by focusing on lightweight design.
In conclusion, the rise of 3-cylinder engines is a response to a changing landscape dictated by fuel efficiency, emissions, and taxation. While they may not appeal to driving enthusiasts, their advantages in terms of cost, efficiency, and adaptation to evolving regulations make them a crucial player in the evolving automotive industry.
Join Us : WhatsApp Channel
FAQ
The primary distinction lies in the number of cylinders. While a 3-cylinder engine has three cylinders, a 4-cylinder engine has four. This cylinder count significantly impacts performance, fuel efficiency, and other aspects.
A 3-cylinder engine tends to be lighter due to having fewer moving parts. The reduced weight can contribute to better fuel economy and emissions.
A 4-cylinder engine generates power at every 90-degree rotation of the crankshaft, whereas a 3-cylinder engine does so at every 120-degree rotation. This difference affects performance and torque delivery.
4-cylinder engines generally offer better refinement due to their balanced firing order. However, with advancements, some 3-cylinder engines now deliver decent performance as well.
Yes, 3-cylinder engines tend to be more fuel-efficient. Their smaller size and reduced friction contribute to better mileage.
Historically, odd-numbered cylinders were considered less balanced and prone to vibrations. However, modern engineering has minimized this issue.
3-cylinder engines may have lower maintenance costs due to fewer components. However, it varies based on the specific model and brand.
Generally, 4-cylinder engines offer better power output. They provide smoother acceleration and higher top speeds.
3-cylinder engines may feel peppier in city driving due to their lighter weight, while 4-cylinder engines excel on highways and during heavy loads.
It depends on your priorities. If you seek fuel efficiency and city-friendly performance, consider a 3-cylinder engine. For refined power and versatility, go for a 4-cylinder engine.